It’s 4.59 pm. You’ve sent the last email you needed to send and you’ve got one arm in your coat when someone looks up and says, “Half day?”

You laugh, because it’s an office joke, and then hear yourself explaining that you started early, worked through lunch and have an appointment at half past five. By the time you’ve got your other arm in, you’ve given a blow-by-blow account of your movements that day that nobody asked for (or was particularly interested in hearing).

I know how it feels to be the person putting on the coat. I’ve also been the person watching everyone else put theirs on and quietly judging them for it.

How about you? Have you ever been both?

My first proper job out of university was at a start-up PR firm, and my boss was my hero. She was smart, fun to be with, liked a drink at the end of a busy day and was bloody good at what she did. I wanted to be like her when I grew up. Admittedly, I was supposed to be a grown-up by then, but you know what I mean.

I wanted to impress her and do my best for her, and I soon learnt that involved staying until she went home. I was happy to work late when there was work to do. On the evenings when there wasn’t, I resented it. It was her business, her baby, and I could see why she wanted to stay. I was less clear about what I was contributing by sitting there pretending to look busy.

You’d think that experience would have made me sympathetic to anyone who wanted to leave on time.

In my next job, I took over a failing temp desk at a recruitment agency and built it into a success. I was working twelve-hour days. And what did I think when other people went home before me?

I looked down on them.

I knew exactly why I was still there. I had a busy temp desk to run. I had no idea what they’d got through on their own desks that day, yet somehow I felt qualified to assess their work ethic from the moment they put their coats on.

When did my rule become everybody else’s?

If you’d asked me why I stayed late at the PR firm, I’d have said, “Because my boss expected us to.” If you’d asked me why I thought my colleagues at the recruitment agency could have been more successful, I’d have said, “Because they all went home before me.”

Both answers seemed perfectly obvious to me at the time. I doubt it would have occurred to me to ask what either of them had to do with me.

I was talking about this on a resilience and wellbeing workshop recently. Sometimes the pressure comes from what’s happening around us. Sometimes it comes from what we expect of ourselves. Quite often, there’s a bit of both.

In some workplaces, there really is an unwritten rule about staying late. You can see who gets praised for putting in the hours and hear what gets said when someone leaves on time. In my case, I took the rule with me when I left the PR firm. And if I’m honest, I think I’d been following a version of it long before I got there.

When I got my GCSE results, I’d done my best and I was pleased with them. My dad said, “Make sure they’re all As next time.”

That line summed up how I’d felt throughout my childhood. The rule I’d picked up was that whatever I did, there was always something more I could have done. That’s what I call a programme, a rule you’ve learnt so well you don’t realise you’re following it.

At the PR firm, there was a very easy way to do a bit more. I could stay a bit longer. By the time I got to the recruitment agency, I thought everybody else ought to do the same. I’d spent all those evenings resenting my boss for making me feel I ought to stay, and there I was, looking down on people who hadn’t even agreed to play by the rule.

What makes me think I need to explain myself?

Maybe you know exactly what’ll be said after you leave. If staying late really is expected in your team, it’s worth finding out when it’s needed and who gets to decide. And if you’re the manager, what do people hear from you? Do you thank them when they’ve done a good job, or mainly when they’ve stayed late to do it?

Maybe it’s been years since anyone said a word and you still feel you ought to have a dentist’s appointment to justify going home. Next time you’ve finished what you needed to do, try leaving on time and notice what you feel the urge to explain. And when someone else gets up to go, what do you assume about them?

I’m my own boss now and I still occasionally feel like I’m getting away with something if I shut my laptop in time to take Cookie out while it’s light. Who, exactly, am I hoping won’t notice?

Cookie’s noticed. She’d have gone an hour ago if it were up to her.

This is the sort of thing I help teams explore in The Confidence Breakthrough™. We look at what gets praised at work, the rules people have picked up about what it takes to be good at their job, and what happens when they start applying those rules to everyone else. If you’d like to have that conversation with your team, get in touch.